Massachusetts anti-wind group apes New Jersey in seeking to reopen EPA permit

Nantucket-based ACK for Whales emulates Save Long Beach Island's success in leveraging Trump project review order to stall sector

A GE Vernova Haliade-X turbine. 22 wind turbines were installed by the time of the blade break incident last year.
A GE Vernova Haliade-X turbine. 22 wind turbines were installed by the time of the blade break incident last year.Photo: Vineyard Wind

A Massachusetts anti-offshore wind group has taken a page from the playbook of its New Jersey peers by seeking to reopen permitting of Iberdrola-controlled Avangrid’s New England Wind array.

Nantucket Residents for Whales (ACK for Whales – previously ACK-Rats) is suing the federal government for approving the giga-scale array in the Massachusetts wind energy area.

In a separate petition, the group aims to emulate New Jersey-based Save Long Beach Island (SLBI)’s success in appealing to the Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) to reopen the Clean Air permit for EDF’s 2.2GW Atlantic Shores array.
SLBI’s appeal hinged on President Donald Trump’s executive order (EO) on wind power that bans new leasing and permitting and requires existing projects to undergo review with an eye towards termination or modification.

The EPA granted SLBI’s petition and withdrew its final permit for Atlantic Shores until the Trump administration finishes its review.

In its petition to the EPA, ACK for Whales highlighted Vineyard Wind’s blade failure last summer as a potential source of uncounted emissions.

A blade collapse shut down construction of the Avangrid-Copenhagen Infrastructure Partners’ owned array in an adjacent lease for months. A root cause analysis found manufacturing defects in turbine OEM GE Vernova’s Canadian factory, leading to the replacement of dozens of blades.

New England Wind analysis and fact sheets “do not appear to account for emissions related to and resulting from blade failures, which would warrant emergency repairs or replacement activities,” the group alleged in its petition.

“Essentially, there are emissions that have been ignored,” Amy DiSibio, Ack for Whales spokesperson, told local media. “So, we just need to make sure that the real facts get out there.”

New England Wind was approved by Bureau of Ocean Energy Management (BOEM) last July with a total project envelope of 2.6GW.

Massachusetts awarded it 791MW in September, though the signing of a final offtake contract has been delayed until the end of this month.

Jason Ryan, spokesperson for sector advocate American Clean Power Association called the petition “yet another baseless and disruptive attempt aimed solely at delaying the development of approved and necessary energy projects.”

“Should EPA concur with these unfounded petitions it would send a chilling message to investors, undermining confidence in the US business environment across all sectors,” he added.

(Copyright)
Published 21 March 2025, 23:49Updated 21 March 2025, 23:49
AmericasUSIberdrolaAvangridCopenhagen Infrastructure Partners